Too Faced
Alternatives to Discontinued Too Faced Favorites at Sephora
Too Faced has a knack for creating products we can’t live without, until they’re gone. From peachy powders to iconic mascaras, some of their discontinued gems still haunt our makeup dreams. Good news: I’ve tracked down alternative shades and formulas at Sephora to fill those voids. These picks capture the essence of Too Faced’s retired stars, so you can keep slaying with fresh favorites. Here’s the lineup!
1. Too Faced Peach Blur Finishing Powder
What It Was: A silky, matte-yet-glowy setting powder from the Peach Perfect line, infused with that signature peach scent. Discontinued when the Peach collection faded out, it was a fan fave for smoothing skin without dulling the vibe.
Sephora Alternatives:
Fenty Beauty Invisimatte Blotting Powder ($34, 0.28 oz)
This universal powder blurs pores and controls shine with a soft, natural finish—think Peach Blur’s smoothing magic without the scent. Perfect for a velvety, airbrushed look.
Laura Mercier Translucent Loose Setting Powder Glow ($40, 1 oz)
A lightweight powder with a hint of radiance, this one echoes Peach Blur’s ability to set makeup while keeping skin luminous. It’s a glowy twist for that Too Faced charm.
2. Too Faced Chocolate Bar Eye Palette
What It Was: A cocoa-scented neutral palette with 16 shades, from creamy nudes to rich browns, discontinued as Too Faced shifted gears. It was a beginner’s dream and a collector’s must-have.
Sephora Alternatives:
Urban Decay Naked3 Palette ($59, 12 x 0.05 oz)
This rose-toned neutral palette offers soft pinks, taupes, and browns that parallel the Chocolate Bar’s wearable range. Blendable and versatile, it’s a shade-for-shade vibe match.
Tarte Tartelette In Bloom Clay Palette ($45, 12 x 0.053 oz)
Warm bronzes, mauves, and nudes in a buttery formula—this one channels the Chocolate Bar’s cozy tones with a matte-to-shimmer mix you’ll adore.
3. Too Faced Natural Nudes Lipstick
What It Was: Creamy, opaque lipsticks in neutral shades with luxe metal packaging, phased out as Too Faced refreshed their lip lineup. These were everyday staples with a chic edge.
Sephora Alternatives:
Sephora Collection #LIPSTORIES Lipstick in ‘Oui!’ ($9, 0.14 oz)
A creamy nude with a soft pink undertone, this shade mirrors the Natural Nudes’ effortless wearability. The satin finish keeps it comfy and chic.
Yves Saint Laurent Rouge Pur Couture Lipstick in ‘Nude Beige’ ($45, 0.13 oz)
This silky neutral beige captures the Natural Nudes’ sophisticated nude tones with a hydrating, satin glow—perfect for that Too Faced elegance.
4. Too Faced Peach Perfect Mattifying Setting Powder
What It Was: A matte-setting powder from the Peach line with a subtle peach scent, loved for its shine control and smooth finish before it was discontinued.
Sephora Alternatives:
Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Microfinishing Loose Powder ($38, 0.28 oz)
This finely milled powder sets makeup with a matte, blurred finish—think Peach Perfect’s oil-taming power with a lightweight feel.
Hourglass Veil Translucent Setting Powder ($49, 0.3 oz)
A soft-focus matte powder that smooths and sets like Peach Perfect, delivering a flawless base with a hint of radiance.
5. Too Faced Better Than Sex Waterproof Mascara
What It Was: A waterproof version of the iconic mascara, delivering dramatic volume and length with smudge-proof staying power, retired as Too Faced streamlined their lineup.
Sephora Alternatives:
Lancôme Monsieur Big Waterproof Mascara ($30, 0.33 oz)
Big, bold lashes with a waterproof formula—this one rivals Better Than Sex’s intensity and holds up through tears or sweat.
Too Faced Damn Girl! 24-Hour Mascara ($28, 0.45 oz)
Not waterproof, but this Too Faced newbie pumps up volume and curl with a smudge-resistant finish—close enough to keep the BTS legacy alive!
Share this content:
Post Comment